Does a Soldier have to accept an Article 15?

• A. Yes, They Must Accept
• B. No, They Can Demand Trial By Court-Martial
• C. They Can Only If They Request
• D. It Is Optional For All Ranks

Answer: (B)

Non-judicial punishment under Article 15 is a quick, disciplinary option for minor offenses, but the accused still has a choice. A Soldier does not have to accept the Article 15 as imposed; they can demand trial by court-martial if they disagree with the punishment or the facts. If they request a court-martial, the case moves to a formal proceeding with more detailed rules and protections, and guilt and punishment are decided by a military judge and, in many cases, a panel. This right to demand a trial by court-martial means acceptance is not mandatory, and the option to go to a formal trial is available across ranks.